Tuesday, March 9, 2010

My Concise Response to Stanley Fish: Absolutely Not!

Stanley Fish's latest effort in the New York Times bears the title "Do You Miss Him Yet," a reference to former President George W. Bush. My concise answer: Absolutely not!

Fish is apparently arguing that as the country moves away from the Bush presidency, it will embrace a more nuanced account of his time in office. Well, that is not a novel claim. In fact, I have made the same argument twice (see here and here), as have many other commentators. But, Fish, that moment has not arrived.

UPDATE: No More Mister Nice Blog has ripped Fish's "evidence" of a Bush revival to shreds.

No comments:

Post a Comment